Intelligent Advisor

High Frequency Trading Like Buying Into First Class, Says FINRA Enforcement Chief

Benefitting from faster access to the markets is akin to buying a first-class plane ticket, and doesn’t sound unfair, said the top cop at Wall Street regulator FINRA.

Speaking on a panel at a conference sponsored by the Practicing Law Institute Friday in New York, J. Bradley Bennett, the chief of enforcement at FINRA, was reacting to a question on high-frequency trading and a discussion of Michael Lewis’ recent book Flash Boys.

Bennett was on a panel with the enforcement heads of the SEC, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Dept. of Justice.

Bennett pointed out the focus of Lewis’ book was on the possible preferential access these traders have and that “their pipes may be faster."

He compared high frequency trading to buying a first-class ticket on an airline, saying these passengers are paying for the benefit of getting on and off the plane first. “Is there anything unfair about that? Doesn’t sound like it to me.” (updated with full quote below)

Bennett also noted that the entire market structure has shifted dramatically. Post World War II, a stock was held, on average, for 4 years. Last year, that dropped to 2.8 seconds, he said. 

Bennett spent two decades as an attorney defending financial advisors and financial services companies before joining Wall Street’s regulatory agency in 2011. He oversees a staff of some 300.

FINRA identified HFT as a regulatory priority in 2014, focusing on “abusive algorithms” that threatened the integrity of the market. But some critics go further, and claim faster access to the exchanges as well as receiving priority data feeds lets these firms act on information faster than others, which is akin to front running.

“Obviously it’s been a topic in the news,” SEC’s head of enforcement Andrew Ceresney told attendees. “It’s an area we’ve been focused on for a period of time,” he added, noting the SEC has several ongoing cases around high-frequency trading.


Bennett's comments, tweeted out by, launched a spirited debate on Twitter over the issue.



Discuss this Blog Entry 1

on Apr 30, 2014

It is time for a new "top cop" at FINRA.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Intelligent Advisor?

The quick hits of information you need to make you a smarter wealth manager


Diana Britton

Diana Britton is the Managing Editor of and REP. Magazine, covering asset management and independent broker/dealers from all angles. A native of Los Angeles, she now lives in...

Ryan W. Neal

Ryan W. Neal is an associate editor for Originally from Sacramento, Calif., Ryan studied English and philosophy at UC Santa Barbara and found his way into journalism. After...
Blog Archive
Investment Category Sponsor Links
Practice Management Category Sponsor Links

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×